Halfway through the project we realized our cleanest model wasn't the most useful one. Our original approach was a single tract-level XGBoost trained on every feature we could pull together — demographics, environment, branch geography, lender concentration, state programs — that ranked tracts by predicted credit-desert risk. The headline metrics were strong and the map looked sharp.
The issue: our model was trained well, but it doesn't tell anyone what to do — and a lot of the strongest features (median income, racial composition, prior loan volume) describe conditions nobody can directly change.
So we split the architecture into two lenses. Diagnostic uses 39 features — demographics, environment, status-quo signals — to show *where* small-business credit risk is concentrated. Influenceable uses 20 features drawn only from the more short-term lending environment — bank branches, CDFI/mission lenders, lender concentration, SSBCI state programs — variables policymakers, lenders, and community lenders can actually move.
We could've been content with just the diagnostic model, but we built the additional lens, because a policy lens—something you can act on—beats one that tells you nothing of how to fix the problem.








